 |
|
The recent dramatic decline in Zomato's share price, exceeding 30% from its all-time high in early December 2024, has sent shockwaves through the investment community. This significant drop followed the company's release of its Q3 FY25 financial results, which revealed a concerning 57% year-on-year decrease in consolidated net profit, down to Rs 59 crore from Rs 138 crore the previous year. While operational revenue showed a positive 64% year-on-year increase, reaching Rs 5,405 crore, the sequential growth of only 13% fell short of market expectations, contributing to the investor unease. This disappointing performance also impacted its competitor, Swiggy, whose shares experienced a parallel decline, although Swiggy's results for the same period were yet to be released at the time of the article's publication. The three-day sell-off following the announcement resulted in a staggering Rs 44,620 crore reduction in Zomato's market capitalization.
Zomato attributed the weaker-than-expected financial performance to its increased investments in its quick-commerce (QC) business, specifically in accelerating the opening of new dark stores and bolstering customer acquisition efforts. This aggressive expansion strategy, mirrored by competitors, signifies a strategic decision to prioritize growth over immediate profitability, a strategy that has incurred short-term pain in the form of increased operational expenses. Siddhartha Khemka, head of retail research at Motilal Oswal Financial Services, highlighted this strategy as the primary driver of the profit decline, suggesting that the impact on profits would likely continue for the next two quarters. This aggressive expansion isn’t unique to Zomato; the competitive landscape necessitates similar investments from its rivals to maintain market share. Khemka further pointed out that Swiggy, unlike Zomato, is not yet profitable in its core food delivery business, suggesting that its path to profitability will be further extended by the necessary investment in quick-commerce.
The contrasting responses from various brokerages underscore the uncertainty surrounding Zomato's future prospects. While some, like Motilal Oswal, maintained a 'Buy' rating, albeit with a reduced price target (from Rs 330 to Rs 270), others adopted a more cautious stance. Nomura and Jefferies both lowered their price targets, citing concerns about the immediate challenges faced by Zomato's Blinkit operations. Macquarie, on the other hand, maintained an 'underperform' rating with a price target significantly lower than current market value, emphasizing escalating competition in the quick-commerce sector as a key factor in their bearish outlook. This divergence in opinion highlights the difficulty in accurately assessing Zomato's long-term potential in light of its current financial situation and the competitive dynamics of the market. However, JM Financial's recommendation suggests a potential buying opportunity for long-term investors, encouraging them to take advantage of the current market downturn to increase their holdings. This positive sentiment contrasts sharply with the more cautious perspectives of other brokerage firms, creating a spectrum of investment advice.
The situation with Zomato underscores the complexities inherent in evaluating high-growth companies that prioritize aggressive expansion over immediate profitability. The substantial investments required to compete effectively in the quick-commerce space, characterized by intense competition and rapid technological advancements, inevitably impact short-term financial performance. While Zomato's strategy might yield substantial returns in the long run, the considerable short-term pain has shaken investor confidence, leading to the significant share price decline. The contrasting opinions of various brokerages highlight the uncertainty surrounding the long-term implications of this strategy. Investors must carefully weigh the potential for future growth against the inherent risks involved in investing in companies that prioritize aggressive expansion over immediate profitability. The debate surrounding Zomato's future underscores the need for a thorough due diligence process and a long-term investment horizon when considering companies operating in highly competitive and rapidly evolving markets.
Dharan Shah, founder of Tradonomy.com, offers a balanced perspective, acknowledging the risks while emphasizing Zomato's potential for long-term expansion. He highlights the importance of Zomato striking a balance between aggressive growth in rapid delivery services and maintaining financial sustainability. This observation underscores the critical need for careful financial management and strategic planning in a highly competitive market, where rapid scaling must be carefully balanced against maintaining a healthy financial position. The ongoing performance of Zomato and its ability to navigate the challenges of aggressive growth and fierce competition will ultimately determine whether its current strategy will bear fruit, or if further corrections to its approach may be required.