 |
|
The compact sedan segment, driven by tax regulations favoring cars under 4 meters in length, has seen a surge in popularity, with the Maruti Suzuki Dzire emerging as a dominant force. This article provides a comprehensive comparison of the Dzire against its rivals, the Honda Amaze, Tata Tigor, and Hyundai Aura, analyzing key aspects like dimensions, powertrain, mileage, and pricing.
In terms of dimensions, the Dzire, Aura, and Amaze share a similar length of 3,995 mm, while the Tigor is slightly shorter at 3,993 mm. The Dzire boasts the widest body at 1,735 mm, followed by the Amaze (1,695 mm), Aura (1,680 mm), and Tigor (1,677 mm). Height-wise, the Tigor takes the lead at 1,532 mm, surpassing the Dzire (1,525 mm), Aura (1,520 mm), and Amaze (1,501 mm). The Amaze stands out with its longer wheelbase of 2,470 mm, providing more legroom compared to the other models with 2,450 mm. Boot space is another crucial factor, where the Amaze offers the most generous capacity at 420L, closely followed by the Tigor (419L), Aura (402L), and lastly, the Dzire with the smallest boot space at 382L.
Powertrain performance is a key selling point for these vehicles. The Amaze and Aura are equipped with 1.2L, 4-cylinder naturally aspirated petrol engines, while the Dzire and Tigor feature 1.2L, 3-cylinder naturally aspirated petrol engines. The Amaze leads in power with 89 bhp, closely followed by the Tigor at 85 bhp, while the Dzire and Aura produce 82 bhp. In terms of torque, the Aura offers the highest figure at 114 Nm, followed by the Tigor (113 Nm), Dzire (112 Nm), and Amaze (110 Nm). The CNG variants offer a different set of power figures. The Tigor leads with 73.4 hp, while the Dzire and Aura deliver slightly lower power at 69.75 hp and 69 hp respectively. For torque in CNG mode, the Dzire offers the highest at 101.8 Nm, followed by the Aura (95.2 Nm) and the Tigor (95 Nm). Notably, the Amaze is currently not available with a factory-fitted CNG kit.
Transmission options are quite similar across the models. The Dzire, Tigor, and Aura are all available with a 5-speed manual transmission (MT) and a 5-speed automated manual transmission (AMT). The CNG variants of the Dzire and Aura exclusively come with a 5-speed MT, while the Tigor offers the option of a 5-speed AMT as well.
Fuel efficiency is a crucial consideration for buyers. In the CNG segment, the Maruti Suzuki Dzire stands out with an impressive efficiency of 33.73 km/kg, followed closely by the Hyundai Aura at 32.85 km/kg. The Tata Tigor, despite its higher power output, offers a slightly lower mileage at 28.06 km/kg. For petrol variants, the Dzire achieves a claimed mileage of 24.79 kmpl with the MT and 25.71 kmpl with the AMT. The Aura boasts a fuel efficiency figure of 20.5 kmpl, while the Honda Amaze delivers 18.6 kmpl with the MT and 16.92 kmpl with the CVT. The Tigor achieves 19.28 kmpl with the MT and 19.69 kmpl with the AMT.
Price is a crucial factor for buyers. The Tata Tigor is the most affordable option with a starting price of Rs 6.30 lakh, followed by the Hyundai Aura at Rs 6.49 lakh, while the Maruti Suzuki Dzire comes in at Rs 6.79 lakh, justifying its higher price with its fuel efficiency and reputation for reliability. The Honda Amaze has the highest starting price at Rs 7.20 lakh, but a new generation of the Amaze is set to launch in India on December 4th.
Ultimately, the choice between the Dzire, Amaze, Tigor, and Aura boils down to individual preferences and priorities. The Dzire stands out with its impressive fuel efficiency and established reputation, the Amaze offers spaciousness and a comfortable ride, the Tigor provides good performance and features, and the Aura strikes a balance between efficiency and practicality. This comprehensive comparison provides valuable insights to help potential buyers make an informed decision.
Source: Maruti Suzuki Dzire Vs Amaze, Aura, Tigor: Price, Specs, Mileage, Boot Space